General aspects of the Indian cause--Public criticism on the
state of Indian researches, and literary storm raised by the new
views--Political rumor--Death of R. Pettibone, Esq.--Delegate
election--Copper mines of Lake Superior--Instructions for a treaty
in the North--Death of Mr. Pettit--Denial of post-office
facilities--Arrival of commissioners to hold the Fond du Lac
treaty--Trip to Fond du Lac through Lake
Superior--Treaty--Return--Deaths of John Adams and Thomas Jefferson.
1826. Feb. 1st. The year opens with unfavorable symptoms
for the Indian cause. The administration is strong in Congress, and
the President favorable to the Indian view of their right to the
soil they occupy east of the Mississippi until it is acquired by
free cession. But the doctrine of state sovereignty contended for by
Georgia, seems to be an element which all the States will, in the
end, unite in contending for. And the Creeks may settle their
accounts with the fact that they must finally go to the West. This
is a practical view of the subject--a sort of political necessity
which seems to outride everything else. Poetry and sympathy are rode
over roughshod in the contest for the race. We feel nothing of this
here at present, but it is only, perhaps, because we are too
remote and unimportant to waste a thought about. Happy
insignificance! As one of the little means of supporting existence
in so remote a spot, and keeping alive, at the same time, the spark
of literary excitement, I began, in December, a manuscript jeu
d'esprit newspaper, to be put in covers and sent from house to
house, with the perhaps too ambitious cognomen of "The Literary
6th. The author of a leading and pungent critique for the
North American Review writes in fine spirits from Washington,
and in his usual literary tone and temper about his review: "Dr.
Sparks' letter will show you his opinion. He altered the manuscript
in some places, and makes me say of--what I do not think and what I
would not have said. But let that pass. I gave him carte blanche,
so I have no right to find fault with his exercise of his
discretion. W. is in a terrible passion. He says that the article is
written with ability, and that he always entertained the opinion
expressed in the review of Heckewelder's work. But he is provoked at
the comments on ----'s work, and, above all, at the compliment to
you. Douglass, who is here, says this is merely Philadelphia
versus New York, and that it is a principle with the former to
puff all that is printed there, and to decry all that is not."
This appears to have been known to Gov. Clinton, and is the ground
of the opinion he expressed of W. to Mr. Conant.
March 6th. Col. De Garmo Jones writes from Detroit that it is
rumored that McLean is to leave the General Post-office Department,
and to be appointed one of the United States Judges.
Mr. L. Pettibone, of Missouri, my companion in exploring the Ozark
Mountains in 1818 and 1819, writes from that quarter that his
brother, Rufus Pettibone, Esq., of St. Louis, died on the 31st July
last. He was a man of noble, correct, and generous sentiments, who
had practiced law with reputation in Western New York. I accompanied
him and his family on going to the Western country, on his way from
Olean to Pittsburgh. His generous and manly character and fair
talents, make his death a loss to the community, and to the growing
and enterprising population of the West. He was one of the men who
cheered me in my early explorations in the West, and ever met me
with a smile.
7th. My sister Maria writes, posting me up in the local news
9th. Mr. Trowbridge informs me that Congress settled the
contested delegate question by casting aside the Sault votes. We are
so unimportant that even our votes are considered as worthless.
However that may be, nothing could be a greater misrepresentation
than that "Indians from their lodges were allowed to vote."
14th. Col. Thomas H. Benton, of the Senate, writes that an
appropriation of $10,000 has been granted for carrying out a clause
in the Prairie du Chien treaty, and that a convocation of the
Indians in Lake Superior will take place, "so that the copper-mine
business is arranged."
17th. Maj. Joseph Delafield, of New York, says that Baron
Lederer is desirous of entering into an arrangement for the exchange
of my large mass of Lake Superior copper, for mineralogical
specimens for the Imperial Cabinet of Vienna.
April 16th. A letter from the Department contains incipient
directions for convening the Indians to meet in council at the head
of Lake Superior, and committing the general arrangements for that
purpose to my hands, and, indeed, my hands are already full. Boats,
canoes, supplies, transportation for all who are to go, and a
thousand minor questions, call for attention. A treaty at Fond du
Lac, 500 miles distant, and the throwing of a commissariat
department through the lake, is no light task.
27th. A moral question of much interest is presented to me in
a communication from the Rev. Alvan Coe. Of the disinterested nature
and character of this man's benevolence for the Indian race, no man
knowing him ever doubted. He has literally been going about doing
good among them since our first arrival here in 1822. In his zeal to
shield them from the arts of petty traders, he has often gone so far
as to incur the ill-will and provoke the slanderous tongues of some
few people. That he should deem it necessary to address me a letter
to counteract such rumors, is the only thing remarkable. Wiser, in
some senses, and more prudent people in their worldly affairs,
probably exist; but no man of a purer, simpler, and more exalted
faith. No one whom I ever knew lives less for "the rewards that
perish." Even Mr. Laird, whose name is mentioned in these records,
although he went far beyond him in talents, gifts, and acquirements
of every sort, had not a purer faith, yet he will, like that holy
man, receive his rewards from the same "Master."
May 2d. Mr. Trowbridge writes me of the death of Wm. W.
Pettit, Esq., of Detroit, a man respected and admired. He loaned me
a haversack, suitable for a loose mineral bag, on my expedition in
8th. Difficulties between the military and citizens continue.
The Postmaster-General declined, on a renewed memorial of the
citizens, to remove the post-office without the garrison. He says
the officers have evinced "much sensibility" on the subject, and
denied that "any restraints or embarrassments" have been imposed,
when every man and woman in the settlement knows that the only way
to the post-office lies through the guard-house, which
is open and shut by tap of drum. Restraints, indeed! Where has the
worthy Postmaster-General picked up his military information?
June 6th. Definite information is received that the
appropriation for the Lake Superior treaty has passed Congress.
10th. Mr. John Agnew, designated a special agent for
preliminaries at Fond du Lac, writes of his prompt arrival at that
place and good progress.
Gov. C. writes: "We must remove the copper-rock, and, therefore, you
will have to provide such ropes and blocks as may be necessary."
22d. The citizens on this frontier, early in the season,
petitioned the Legislative Council for the erection of a new county,
embracing the Straits of St. Mary's and the Basin of Lake Superior,
proposing to call it Chippewa, in allusion to the tribe occupying
it. Maj. Robert A. Forsyth, of Detroit, M.C., writes of the success
of the contemplated measure.
July 4th. The proposed treaty of Fond du Lac has filled the
place with bustle for the last month. At an early hour this morning
expectation was gratified by the arrival of His Excellency, Gov.
Cass, accompanied by the Hon. Thomas L. McKenney, Commissioner of
Indian Affairs. They reached the village in boats from Mackinac.
These gentlemen are appointed by the President to hold the
conferences at Fond du Lac.
10th. Everything has been put in requisition for the last six
days to facilitate the necessary embarkation. Jason could not have
been more busy in preparing for his famous expedition to Argos. The
military element of the party consisted of a company of the 2d
Infantry, with its commissariat and medical department, numbering,
all told, sixty-two men. It was placed under the command of Capt.
Boardman. They embarked in three twelve-oared barges, and formed the
advance. The provisions, presents of goods, and subsistence supplies
of the commissioners' table, occupied four boats, and went next. I
proceeded in a canoe allege with ten men, with every
appendage to render the trip convenient and agreeable. Col. McKenney,
struck with "the coach-and-six" sort of style of this kind of
conveyance, determined to take a seat with me, and relying upon our
speed and capacity to overtake the heavy boats, we embarked a day
later. The whole expedition, with flags and music, was spread out
over miles, and formed an impressive and imposing spectacle to the
natives, who saw their "closed lake," as Superior was called in
1820, yield before the Anglo-Saxon power. The weather was fine, the
scenery enchanting, and the incidents such as might fill a volume1.
We were eighteen days in traversing the lake by its shores and bays.
The distance is about 530 miles, which gives an average of thirty
miles per day.
On reaching the post of Fond du Lac, of St. Louis, near the point
where that bold stream deploys below the Cabotian Mountains2,
we found a large assemblage of Indians from every part of the
wide-spread Chippewa territories. It embraced delegations from the
extreme sources of the Mississippi, the Rainy Lake borders, and Old
Grand Portage, besides the entire American borders of Lake Superior
and the Rice Lake region, the sources of the Wisconsin, Chippewa,
and St. Croix valleys. The negotiations were held under a large
bower, supported by posts, and provided with rude seats. The
principles of the treaty of Prairie du Chien, of 1825, were fully
explained and assented to. They ceded the right to explore and take
away the native copper and copper-ores, and to work the mines and
minerals in the country. They agreed to surrender the murderers
still inland, who belonged to the misguided war party of 1824. They
fully acknowledged the sovereign authority of the United States, and
disclaimed all connection whatever with foreign powers. They
stipulated that the boundary lines of the treaty of Prairie du Chien
should be carried out in 1827 with the Menomonies and Winnebagoes,
in the region of the sources of the Fox, Wisconsin, and Menomonee
rivers. They provided for an Indian school at St. Mary's, and made
some further important stipulations respecting their advance in the
arts and education, through the element of their half-breeds. The
effects of this treaty were to place our Indian relations in this
quarter on a permanent basis, and to ensure the future peace of the
frontier. My agency was now fixed on a sure basis, and my influence
fully established among the tribes. During the treaty I had been the
medium of placing about forty silver medals, of the first, second,
and third classes, on the necks of the chiefs. A list of their names
While the Commissioners were engaged in the treaty, an effort was
made, under their direction, to get out the large copper-boulder on
the Ontonagon. It was entrusted to Col. Clemens, of Mount Clemens,
and a Mr. Porter. The trucks and ropes taken inland by them proved
inadequate. They then piled up the dry trees in the valley on the
rock, and set them on fire. They found this effort to melt it
inefficacious. They then poured on water from the river on whose
brink it lays. This cracked off some of the adhering rock. And this
attempt to mutilate and falsify the noblest specimen of native
copper on the globe was the result of this effort.
The whole expedition re-embarked on the 9th of August, and being now
relieved of its heavy supplies and favored with winds, returned to
the Sault St. Marie on the 18th of that month.
No sooner were we arrived at St. Mary's than we were informed of the
remarkable coincident deaths, on the 4th July, 1826, of John Adams
and Thomas Jefferson, the second and third Presidents of the United
Among the letters accumulated during my absence, was one of Aug. 2d,
from Gov. Clinton, requesting some wild rice for foreign
Another one was from my excellent friend Conant, of N.Y., who, with
a fine sensitive mind, just appreciation of facts, and no ordinary
capacity, appears to be literally breaking down in health and
spirits, although still a young man. In a joint letter to Mrs. S.
and myself, he says: "It appears you do not escape afflictions and
visitations to teach you 'how frail you are,' how liable at any
moment to render up to Him who gave them, your spirit and your life.
Mr. S.," he adds, in evident allusion to my excess of "hope," "firm
in body and ambitious in his pursuits, does not, I suppose, give
over yet, and can scarcely understand how anybody should tire of
life, and look at its pursuits with disgust."
Among my unread letters was one, Aug. 28th, from a Mr. Myer and Mr.
Cocke, of Washington, District of Columbia, who propose to establish
a periodical to be called "The Potomac Magazine," and solicit
contributions. These abortive attempts to establish periodicals by
unknown men are becoming more frequent as population increases in
the land. It is felt truly that the number of readers must
increase, but it is a mistake to suppose that they will read
anything but the very best matter from the first sources, European
and American. It is, at any rate, a mistake to suppose that a man
who has attained reputation in any branch of science, literature, or
general knowledge, should not seek the highest medium of
communicating it, or that he would throw away his time and efforts
in writing for these mere idealities of magazines without the strong
inducements of either fame, money, or, at least, personal
E.A. Brush, Esq., of Detroit, writes (Aug. 28th) from Mackinac, that
honors were performed that day by the military authorities on the
island, in commemoration of the deaths of Adams and Jefferson. "The
obsequies have this morning commenced here; but at this moment it is
rather difficult to select the report of a cannon, at intervals of
half an hour, from the claps of thunder at those of half a minute."
Aug. 20th. Mr. Robert Stuart, agent of the A.M. Fur Co.,
writes a letter of congratulations on the good policy to result from
placing a sub-agent at La Pointe, in Lake Superior, a location where
the interior tricks of the trade may be reported for the notice of
the government. The selection of the sub-agent appointed by
Commissioner McKenney is gall and wormwood to him. He strives to
conceal the deep chagrin he feels at the selection of Mr. George
Johnston as the incumbent.
1: Vide "Sketches of a Tour to the Lakes, of the
Character and Customs of the Chippewa Indians, and of Incidents
connected with the Treaty of Fond du Lac, by Thomas L. McKenney."
Baltimore, Fielding Lucas, 1827; one vol. 8vo., 493 pp.
2: From Cabot.
This site includes some historical
materials that may imply negative stereotypes reflecting the culture or language
of a particular period or place. These items are presented as part of the
historical record and should not be interpreted to mean that the WebMasters in
any way endorse the stereotypes implied.
Personal Memoirs of a Residence of Thirty Years with the
Indian Tribes on the American Frontiers, 1851
Years with the Indians